It’s very funny to watch people read a book you’ve already read. Granted, it was a year ago, but I’ve already read The Great Gatsby, and watched the movie. I get a certain kind of knowing bliss when I hear the class make predictions or try to figure out what a certain character is going to do later. And when people make predictions in the group chat, I basically laugh out loud. It’s given me a kind of godlike feeling, which is most certainly how Mrs. Valentino feels watching students read the same books every year. It has given me a strange bit of insight however, that I never thought about before; students always tend to jump to deaths. I cannot count how many times in class I’ve heard that this character or that character was probably going to die by the end of the novel. It’s insane how English students can get so incredibly morbid about fictional characters, going as far as to predict how they will die. This makes sense though, all the books we’ve been required to read up until this point have been incredibly dark, switching from being fun and light hearted books in elementary school to dark and depressing topics in middle school like A Tale of Two Cities. This kind of switch in education aligns with how the switch in teaching of children occurs as well. Instead of learning about fun and interesting topics with interactive lessons. Middle school and high school brought along a slew of dark and confusing topics with boring lessons of listening to people lecture. Now that I’m done going through that rant, I just want to say one concluding thing: never trust your first prediction, it’s probably wrong.
I never realized this but it's so true. We predict character deaths in great gatsby almost like we're watching a horror movie or smthn. Honestly I wish there were more happy surprises, but I feel like part of the reason why we don't do that anymore is 1) happy endings are unrealistic and 2) after a while, they can get kinda boring. But that being said I truly wish high school lessons had some more interactive things :(
ReplyDeleteWow, that's such an interesting perspective from someone who knows all that's happened. I feel like deaths are for dramatic effect in movies, causing us to instantly guess that there's a death in every movie so that they could interest us/shock us. For books though, especially if it's in our curriculum, it's always these purely innocent figures wrongfully dying to teach us a lesson. Maybe it's just that we're constantly reading/seeing these deaths that we just assume there to be one all the time.
ReplyDeleteIt's so true that when we read books in class we immediately go to the dark /morbid side of things! I guess as students we're just used to seeing multiple deaths within each novel we read. I can't think back to one I've read without any fatalities! It's also super fun to be in that omniscient position when you know what happens and everyone else doesn't. That can make everything heard in class a little more interesting, and discussing the book a little more fun.
ReplyDelete